Why does Beth Dutton hate her brother Jamie so much on the hit show, Yellowstone? Why is Samantha not in the Sex and the City reboot. Before his dark act, Beth had no reason to hate Jamie. With Dutton family tensions rising we reveal what has been said so far about whether we'll see Kevin Costner leaving Yellowstone By Emma Shacklock Elaborating on the last point, Beth promised to murder Jamie if she proved his involvement in the plan. Beth seems to think that Jamie is cruel and selfish. We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. In the compelling narrative of Yellowstone, the intense sibling feud between Beth and Jamie Dutton stands out as a central plot point, often leaving viewers intrigued. I think the relationship with Jamie and Beth is so toxic. Kim Kardashian's Viral Claims About Her Hard-Partying On The Fourth Come Shortly After She Admits To Drinking Again, Speak Now (Taylor's Version) Just Came Out, But Taylor Swift's Fourth Of July Post Is Giving Big 1989 Energy, Carson Daly Admits He Hated American Idol And It Had A Big Effect On His Initial Reaction When He Got Offered The Voice. 'Yellowstone' Fans Have Wild Theories About Why Beth Dutton Hates Jamie When I read it, I-- I-- I really had a hard time with that line. It seems plausible, and it would explain why John did not tell Beth to lay off Jamie sooner. Beth had her tubes ties. Now the shows on hiatus fans are left to wonder what lies in store for Beth, Jamie and their family going forwards. Given that Rip does not seem to have an issue with Jamie and her father does, maybe Jamie did something to John himself? During a flashback scene, fans found out why Beth hates Jamie so much. published 30 July 2020 (Image credit: Paramount Network) Yellowstone has turned the tension in the Dutton household up about a million-fold, with John Dutton finally learning why his daughter. Shes produced content for the likes of Culture Trip, WhatCulture and Prague.TV and started writing for Screen Rant in 2019 firstly as a news writer before progressing onto writing mini-features. No way a surgeon proceeds on a minor without her fathers consent. According to a reveal by Yellowstone stars, Jamie believes he acted in his sisters best interest by having Beth sterilized. He transported her to a native American abortion clinic without telling her, where the procedure includes sterilization. Now that weve witnessed the season 4 finale, we have our answer. The Worst Thing Beth Dutton Has Done On Yellowstone - Looper Why Beth Hates Jamie So Much : r/YellowstonePN - Reddit For global reference, this was also a tactic used by Nazis. The post creator questions just why Jamie is such a disliked person on the show. Up until that point, his sense of loyalty seemed pretty consistent. Here's an interesting take from star Wes Bentley about the sibling rivalry: There's obviously something big for Beth that Jamie did that I'm not fully certain Jamie's aware of. Along with movies and television, she is passionate about competitive figure skating. Despite there being no official announcement just yet, Cole Hauser (who plays Rip Wheeler) appeared on the HALL Wines Virtual Happy Hour and explained the positive news: [Yellowstone creator] Taylor [Sheridan] is working on it right now, and I think we will be back sometime in July. Kaycee? After learning about their sibling history, it's clear why Beth has so much resentment towards Jamie. Not surprisingly, its origins have spawned a few vivid theories from Yellowstone 's fanbase. Why does Beth hate Jamie on Yellowstone? Some fans speculate that his mother was Evelyns sister or somehow important to John. And to this day, she hates Jamie with every fiber of her being for it. @Mike,The writers messed up. The fact that they have very different ideas about values, morals, and the world in general is also a reason for their toxic relationship. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site. A RIFF on what makes the great outdoorsgreat. Why do John and Beth hate Jaime??? : r/YellowstonePN - Reddit After last weeks brutal installment saw Malcolm Beck become Dutton enemy #1, the family is gearing up to take him out. If he explicitly told her to let Jamie live, she might well change her plans. Some thought that it all stems from their mother's untimely. At the time, the actress expressed concern that fans would turn on Beth once they found out why she treats Jamie with such hostility: "I hope it won't make people hate her. In Beth's teenage years, she became pregnant and sought help from her older brother Jamie. Why Does Beth Hate Jamie? As a teenager, Beth got pregnant with Rips baby and asked Jamie for help. A mindset. She seemed to have felt that way long before Yellowstones current season. 5: Young Beth is staring at herself in the mirror, rubbing her belly. Last year, Yellowstone 's co-creator, Taylor Sheridan, teased that Season 3 would take a . I believe Beth hates Jamie so much, because he did something to her and Rip's relationship when they were younger. Beth and Jamie have vastly different ideas about morals, ethics, and personal conduct. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. John explained his thinking behind his decision, and Beth seemed to calm down. Emma is a Senior Lifestyle Writer with six years of experience working in digital publishing. Thanks for that. She then ties her overshirt as if hiding something. Through manipulation, Randall was able to win Jamie to his cause and convince him to fight for the Yellowstone empire. I cant tell you how many times Ive read Beth Dutton is my spirit animal on Twitter and in the comments, but for some fans, from the way she treats her brother Jamie Dutton (Wes Bentley), to the way she treats Carter (Finn Little), to the way she never has to answer to anybody fans are downright fed up with Beth. Why Does Beth Hate Jamie So Much In Yellowstone? - Vim Buzz The reason Beth hates Jamie : r/YellowstonePN - Reddit The Duttons present a united front to whoever lays an eye on their family members and property, the Yellowstone Ranch. Yellowstone Finally Reveals Why Beth Hates Jamie and My God, Now I Hate Jamie, Too, This Week's 'Yellowstone' Features Wolf Voyeurism, 'Yellowstone' Has a New Villain in Josh Holloway, The Ultimate 'Yellowstone' Season 2 Refresher, How 'The Bear' Reaffirmed Fine Dining's Delights, Your Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads. However, like any family, they are privy to disagreements among themselves. Yellowstone remains the most surprising series on cable. In a shocking revelation of Yellowstone Season 3, we found out that Jamie is in fact adopted. Helpfully for him, she did, and so it seems both Dutton siblings are going to try and kill each other first. At the start of the series, the Duttons hatred for Jamie is not obvious, save for Beth Dutton. "I feel really bad for Jamie sometimes. Sadly, that love has long gone by Yellowstone's latest season as Beth has another of other reasons for hating her brother. Helen is a lifelong fan of the horror genre which started in the 1980s when films like Gremlins and Cats Eye scared the life out of her as a kid. Yellowstone season 4: Why does Beth hate Jamie on Yellowstone? Her, him and JD. Likely for good reason, neither feels free to inform John Dutton, and Rips tenure on the show would not have lasted long. But based on the Twitter reactions alone, it looks like Jamie's the one who has to win back everybody's love (if that's even possible at this point). Instead it feels like she grows more abusive and hateful as time goes by., Her hate filled monologues are getting ridiculous now. Therefore, it is easy to see why the brother-sister duo dont see eye to eye, but it doesn't stop there as the real reason for their broken relationship is revealed in season three, episode five, titled Cowboys And Dreamers. Beth also despises Jamie for repeatedly betraying the family that took him in. In "Cowboys and Dreamers," it was revealed that a young Beth Dutton turned to Jamie for help when she discovered that she was pregnant. Jamie also believes she cant expose his crimes without revealing Johns which is probably true meaning Beth might think she has no other choice anyway. @Evie, I may stop watching Yellowstone as this sibling rivalry seems too off base and too intense. Published 13 January 23. It's no secret that Beth hates Jamie with a fiery passion, and after he took her to get an abortion at a young age that resulted in her permanent infertility, she may have every right to be. The series is also available to stream online through iTunes and Amazon Prime Video, as well as extensions Hulu Live TV, YouTube TV, FuboTV and DirecTV. It is likely that John Dutton adopted Jamie since he knew the Randall family and wanted to protect Jamie from any further harm. Does John Dutton hate Jamie? Why Does Beth Hate Jamie? Below is a brilliant video of Beth and Jamies troubled friendship: Beth can never forgive Jamie for agreeing to a hysterectomy without her knowledge. Yes, please! It just so happens that she is now in a prime position to chastise him. Mar 14. And the mid-season finale ended with Kayce and Monica talking about Johns proposal to him that hell run the ranch whilst Rip is in Texas. Does John Dutton Hate Jamie? The Truth Behind Their Relationship But why does Beth hate Jamie in Yellowstone, what happened to them in the mid-season finale and what can we expect going forwards? Ahead of the season 3 premiere, Kelly Reilly, who plays Beth, spoke to Good Housekeeping about her character's complex relationship with Jamie: "This isn't just a sibling rivalry. But when Carter calls her mom, she practically tears his head off, sending poor Carter, a kid desperately in need of love, away crying. Although unexpected, Jamies adoption story explained a lot about the way the Duttons treat him. Visit our corporate site. Beth hates Jamie on Yellowstone because he is the reason she cant have biological children. Future Publishing Limited Quay House, The Ambury, That is one of the big questions that has. Just before he found out she was pregnant, Jamie has a breakdown when John is blaming him for Beth's hysterectomy. First, the show presents Beth as an unknowing participant in the procedure but, almost certainly, the clinician-in-charge would have alerted Beth to the full process, including ramifications, so to gain her informed consent; and, this, even more so given Beths non-Native status and the clinicians residence, there, on planet Earth with the rest of the county who, undoubtedly, had heard of the Dutton Ranch. Beth became pregnant as a teen with Rip's child and turned to Jamie for support. When he found out John is not his biological father, Jamie sought out his real dad for answers. Granted, everybody cant be attacked and blown up every season, but Season 4 seemed to do more to set the table for future events as opposed to advancing the story in real time. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. Thus, only one rational means of Beths sterilization remains: tubal ligation. Therefore, it is easy to see why the brother-sister duo does not see eye to eye. AND??? Yellowstone is the brainchild of actor-writer-director and all-round industry talent Taylor Sheridan the man who penned the Oscar-nominated script for neo-western Hell Or High Water and later received critical acclaim for directing fellow genre favorite Wind River. The nurses had told Jamie how they could only sterilize Beth and she would no longer be able to have children. Many fans of the neo-western series think this suggests Beth was once pregnant with Rip's child and Jamie either did something to cause a miscarriage or persuaded her to get an abortion that possibly left her unable to have any more kids. However, despite all he took away from her, Jamie has always acted confused about her sisters hatred towards him. Jamie has started the process to get John impeached as Governor and after a furious Beth confronted him he said that she also knows deep down that John is running the Yellowstone ranch into the ground. While Chicago P.D. Then again, after Market Equities comes after her for corporate espionage, she might end up being responsible for taking the entire family down. Several issues, here. As expected, fans rallied around Beth. The decision Jamie takes under the circumstances leads to him being the subject of lifelong hatred from his sister. Pro stylists explain how to copy the look, Prince William wasn't eating and 'hid away' ahead of Harry and Meghan's Oprah interview, according to royal insiders, By Caitlin Elliott Throughout the entire run of Yellowstone, Jamie had been trying to win the approval of his father - something that came so easily for his siblings Kayce and Beth. Many fans thought Kayces story was out of left field, we got a TON of Jimmy and the Four Sixes (opening the door for a spinoff), we even saw 1883 make its way into the show via flashbacks. Therefore, Beth's disdain for her brother is apparent, but the foundation of these feelings remains unclear until the previously mentioned episode. Along with Esquire, his work has appeared in NYLON, Vulture, and USA Today. How is Kevin Costners Yellowstone character linked to 1923 and could we have just had confirmation of John Duttons grandmother? NY 10036. Something big must have led Beth to think that Jamie is such a selfish and disloyal member of the family. What led to this toxic rift, and why on earth is Beth so continually cruel to her brother? Taking her to an abortion clinic at the Indian Reservation was the only way to keep the incident from John and protect Rip as well. BA1 1UA. However, we cannot figure out the reason behind Beth's continued cruelty towards Jamie and her constant barrage of insults thrown his way to the point where she has also told him to kill himself. Helen Armitage is a freelance writer based in the UK who has been writing online since late 2013. Tune in to see if viewers ever learn why Beth hates Jamie so much when new episodes of Yellowstone Season 2 air Wednesdays at 10 p.m. Since Beth now has a husband and still cant have kids, shes essentially adopted Carter, who reminds them both of a young Rip. A recent Reddit thread discusses the relationship between Jamie and Beth Dutton. 'Yellowstone' Star Kelly Reilly Teases Why Beth Hates Jamie So Much Why Do Beth and Jamie Hate Each Other on Yellowstone? But cheesy 1980s soap opera this is not. ago But Beth keeps talking as though Jamie MADE her go to the clinic and get an abortion. While most states abandoned the tactics in the States following World War II, the practice of sterilization was still common throughout the '70s. The Dutton clan on neo-western drama Yellowstone is hardly the most functional family unit, but why does Beth hate her brother Jamie so much? However, the Yellowstone fandom thinks there may be something else at work that explains Beths hatred for Jamie something so terrible it would spur her to tell him to commit suicide and threaten to destroy any future happiness he might have. 'Yellowstone' TV: Are There Secrets To Why John Dutton 'Hates' Jamie? Therefore, Beths disdain for her brother is apparent, but the foundation of these feelings remains unclear until the previously mentioned episode. Now, Yellowstone may reveal that Beth has undergone a failed reversal procedure but given its possibility, coupled with the likelihood of Beths informed consent (back when) and Jamies lack of options, Beths abiding hatred of Jamie feels misplaced. One of the most contentious relationships on the show is between siblings Beth and Jamie Dutton, who often butt heads with one another. If youre wondering why does Beth hate Jamie in Yellowstone youre probably not alone as things have escalated dangerously between the siblings over recent seasons. My in-laws love her, but Ive always thought her character was bizarre and the writers let her set the tone for how others see Jamie. During Sunday's episode, fans finally got the answers they've been searching for after three seasons of deep-seated hatred. Thing is, the reversal procedures on tubal ligation have a 50% to 80% success rate. While plenty of siblings have a love-hate dynamic, Beth and Jamies seems especially vitriolic and Yellowstones first season offered a few clues as to why. 8 75 comments Add a Comment MerelyWhelmed1 4 mo. The only time Jaime acts against John is when John pushes and punishes him. Heres how it works. And so full of pain for her. He went to Harvard, became a prominent lawyer, and protected his family to the best of his abilities. No, Beth doesnt kill Jamie in the recent finale. The Dutton sibling's relationship has been in question since the start of the show and it looks like things are just heating up. . As long as he stays quiet, he might think he's not risking any reveals. Understanding the ramifications of the decision, Jamie agrees but without informing Beth of the truth. As a lawyer and a former Attorney-General Jamie also hasnt made things easy for his father and anything that threatens John is something Beth wont tolerate. Of course, there's no way to know for sure until Season 3 gets underway, but I'd bet money there was a teen pregnancy (that Rip was not necessarily aware of) and Jamie had something to do with the loss of the baby. Conclusion. Helen loves a good movie musical too and has probably watched The Rocky Horror Picture Show, Hedwig And The Angry Inch, The Blues Brothers and Little Shop Of Horrors more times than is healthy. A lifestyle so perfectly captured by the country greats of yesterday, but still alive and well today in artists who truly get it. Siblings Jamie (Wes Bentley) and Beth (Kelly Reilly) cant seem to get along. This viewer is having a tough time coming up with a lot of possibilities. Why does Beth hate Jamie on Yellowstone? | The US Sun Yellowstone's Kevin Costner Shares How John Dutton Feels About Jamie Published 6 July 23, Although no official air date for part 2 of season 5 of Yellowstone has yet been announced, fans are wondering if Rip is a goner. But I think the reason why all of that exists is because she loved him.. In an interview with Entertainment Tonight, actress Kelly Reilly who portrays Beth in Yellowstone raised an interesting point about her character: I feel really bad for Jamie sometimes. There are a number of fan theories floating around the Internet: maybe. Like, wouldnt Beth realistically calm down over the course of 25 or so years? Why Does Beth Hate Jamie? Complicated Siblings In Yellowstone England and Wales company registration number 2008885. How Jamie and Beths troubled relationship will come into play is another story. As a teenager, Beth got pregnant with Rip's baby and asked Jamie for help. Kelly Reilly discussed Beth telling Jamie to kill himself in last weeks episode, saying: Does she mean it? For all his life, Jamie has dutifully followed the path John Dutton assigned him. The answer is yes, and there's no way of denying that strong tension between them. .css-lwn4i5{display:block;font-family:Neutra,Helvetica,Arial,Sans-serif;font-weight:bold;letter-spacing:-0.01rem;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;text-align:center;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-lwn4i5:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}@media(min-width: 48rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}See A.J. Laugh with us. Unfortunately, Jamie's actions are ultimately what led his sister to feel hatred towards him. Yellowstone: Why Does Beth Hate Jamie So Hard? - CINEMABLEND But as the series has moved along, her hate for him continues to grow more and more intense, and some fans think shes gone overboard. From Texas to Tennessee, Appalachia to Bakersfield, Whiskey Riff is THE unapologetic voice of the country music fan. We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back. The only obstacle to this is John himself as she posed the question of whether they should permanently eliminate Jamie to him in the mid-season finale but its not clear what her fathers view on that is.

Events For Psychology Students, Bullet Gta San Andreas Location, Canobie Lake Park Accidents, Sbi Fd Interest Rates 2023 For Senior Citizens, Articles W